Your Go-To Sports Card Destination in Cortland
Dug Out Sports Cards stands out as a beloved sports card store located in the heart of Cortland. This well-stocked shop offers an impressive selection that satisfies collectors at every level. Customers appreciate the welcoming environment and the knowledgeable staff, especially Pat, who is praised for his friendly and generous approach toward newcomers to the hobby. Whether you’re hunting for a rare find or seeking expert advice, this shop delivers with personalized service and a genuine passion for sports cards.
Visitors often highlight the attentive customer care, noting that even if a particular item isn’t in stock, orders can be placed without any price markups. This integrity, combined with a well-curated inventory, makes Dug Out Sports Cards a trusted hub for enthusiasts in Cortland and beyond.
Add Review
Read More Reviews
Michael McCabe
a week agoAwesome shop, reasonable prices.Pat is a great guy - will be stopping here again!
1123JGilbert
a month agoGreat selection of sports cards and memorabilia, also sells MTG and Pokemon cards. Been buying cards here for 25 years, its a great little store.
Tina
3 months agoHad exactly what I was looking everywhere for. Very nice little card shop. Seemed well stocked with a very sweet and helpful gentleman to help me behind the counter.
Leclar Dennis
3 months agoRalph Pistor
5 months agoMostly new sports cards, there were a few older baseball cards, that I was looking for, in the glass cases. Confused on the prices since some cases were marked 50% off and others weren't. No bargaining on the price. Turned out all glass cases cards were 50% off. One thing that was mind boggling to me, there were boxes and boxes of older baseball cards behind the counter that the owner said weren't for sale. A bit odd, you have a card shop and have cards in the shop in view that are not for sale. The owner can do anything he wants, I get it I don't really know how to rate the shop since it is well stocked, just not what I was looking for