Buffalo’s Fall Favorite: Mayer Bros Cider Mill
Mayer Bros Cider Mill in Buffalo, NY is a seasonal treasure that draws crowds eager to indulge in fresh apple cider and a wide selection of delicious treats. This iconic cider mill is famous for its apple cider donuts, hailed as some of the best in decades, alongside vanilla and maple cider options that delight every palate. The welcoming atmosphere and high-quality offerings make it a cherished fall tradition.
Beyond cider and donuts, Mayer Bros provides an array of specialty products including pies, pumpkin loaves, honey, mustards, hot sauces, and mixes for muffins and cheese balls. Guests enjoy apple cider slushies and cheese curds on-site, with picnic tables nearby for a relaxed outing. Although it can get busy, arriving early ensures you can fully appreciate this vibrant hub of seasonal flavors and community spirit.
Add Review
Read More Reviews
R C
4 months agoThis is a must visit staple in Buffalo, especially in the fall. They not only have great apple cider but also sell vanilla, maple, and best of all, a large selection of apple donuts. They also sell pies and pumpkin loaves. It is also a great place to buy gifts as they also offer honey, mustards, hot sauces, mixes for muffins or cakes, and mixes for cheese balls. I love their apple cider slushies and cheese curds.
Megan Marrano
3 months agoGreat products, fresh cider, but rude staff. The maple syrup was missed priced. It was labeled $10.98 but we were charged $26 for it. Mentioned it to the teen working the register and was told there is nothing they can do about. Told them they might want to mention it to someone so it can be fixed and was told "oh whatever".
Beth Fitzgerald
1 month agoFresh Little pricey but it's high quality and you get your money's worth and then some. Best donuts I've had in 30 years .my profession actually was a donut fryer they beat my donuts . No questions asked 100 % amazing. They do more than just a cider and donuts though they have really good coffee excellent choices different choices. Fudge, jams , fresh honey, cheese curd, candy apple.. and so on They're not open very often apparently when they are get there early stand in line there is going to always be a line there's no way of getting around that. They make their own popcorn things outside by the door when you're walking in and out. There are some bags of popcorn inside tied up There are some picnic tables across the street where you been parking. Or you can park a little ways down and you can all do like a tailgate party kind of thing
Tyla Kells
1 year agoThe best time to go is very early in the morning, so you get the freshest donuts. The summer time is difficult with cider slushies because they melt very quickly. Great idea is to bring a corksicle or something else to help keep it cold. Store is cute but small. Have other things besides donuts and cider. Pics of candy apples. They have all different flavors. My fave is the chocolate caramel sea salt apple. They don't always have the same variety. The last time I was there they did not have the smores one. I like the fact that I can come here and then go to the Niagara co-op after! All in all, a solid 4 stars.
Chantal Theresa
2 months agoThe dreamiest place esp during fall. Be sure to try the apple cider donuts and slushies